Category Archives: Musings

Anthropomorphising.


Sunday, October 15th, 2017 | Filed under Musings




(ORIGINALLY POSTED OCTOBER, 2010)

So I ask you… do we, as humans, have any other frame of reference to describe the characteristics or behavior of our animals?

HOW THIS THOUGHT ERUPTED IN MY BRAIN

As some of you readers may know, one of the HORSE AND MAN posts called, “The Hardest Fix” was re-posted (with some edits) in HORSE AND RIDER magazine in August.  Yay!

Of course, with every article printed in a magazine, there comes reader responses.  Lo and behold, in the October issue of HORSE AND RIDER magazine, there was a box devoted to the reader responses to “The Hardest Fix”. Yay again!

But, not all the responses were positive.  There was this rancher’s viewpoint which I have reprinted here.

I THOUGHT ABOUT THIS FOR A FEW WEEKS

OK, I don’t want this discussion to come across as a writer (me) who has to have total agreement from readers.  I’ve certainly received comments from readers correcting me or challenging my opinions.  I have had readers “unsubscribe” – ouch.  I know I’m not going to please everyone all the time.   And, I know that even though I try really to write posts without errors, it doesn’t always happen.

SO WHAT BOTHERED ME ABOUT THIS PARTICULAR COMMENT?

What bothered me about the above remark was something that runs deep with me.  He touched on what I call the Superiority of Humans towards animals.   It really bugs me when people think animals deserve less from this life or this planet simply because they are not humans.  And, I become really upset when humans think they can treat an animal any way they wish because animals don’t have emotion.

Besides my personal feeling about animal rights, I also felt great sorrow for this rancher’s horse and dog.  I also wondered how he lived each day on the ranch without feeling the gifts of animal nature all around him…  How could he feel the soft breeze or the harsh winds but not feel the contentment or the upset in the beings around him – who work so closely with him?

DISSECTION

So, I decided to make sure I understood the definition of anthropomorphism so I could be sure to understand what the rancher was saying in his remark.

I looked it up:  “the attribution of human characteristics or behavior to a god, animal, or object.”

OK, is it possible to attribute characteristics in any other way other than in a human way?  I, as a human, cannot attribute characteristics in an equine manner.  How could I?  I’m not a horse.  I mean, if I say a god is a skittish or spooky god, I’m still defining it from my perspective as a human even though those descriptors we, as humans, use to describe an equine.  However, those descriptors of these attributes are concocted or measured or defined from our human viewpoint.  So, is there any other way to describe the behavior of an animal?

Now, I’m not saying that describing an animal through our viewpoint is necessarily correct.  I’m merely saying that we have no other vantage point in which to do so.

I cannot think like a dog or equine or a god or an object.  I can’t even think like you.  I can only think like me.  A dog can only think for himself as a dog and a horse can only think for himself as a horse.  And, thereinlies the communication breakdown.  That is why we humans try to put ourselves in the viewpoint of another species so that we can try to better understand them.

Was Jane Goodall using primate expressions to describe her subjects?  Nope.  She wrote reports in human language.  And, in those reports she described the interactions of the primates using her only frame of reference.

And, I kinda think dogs and equines attempt this cross communication as well.  For example, I don’t think a horse bangs on a tree or a rock out in the wild when he is trying to get another horse’s attention.  And, I don’t think a dog. left to his own devices, would do tricks on his own when he wants a treat.  Banging on a gate or doing a trick for a cookie are ways that our animal friends try to bridge the gap.

MAYBE THE RANCHER IS JUST SAYING THAT ANIMALS DON’T HAVE EMOTION

If animals are not emotional, why do they all come to the barn when I’m crying there?  Why do they flee from a helicopter?  Why do babies cry for their mothers?  Why do longtime companions pine for their lost friends?  Why do horses explore something in tandem?  Why do they retaliate?  Why do they honor a good leader?

ON THE FRONT PAGE OF MSNBC TODAY

So, as I’m writing this today, freak of timing strikes and this is the article I see:

Click image to read article

This article is accompanied by this photo:

So, I kinda think the rancher may have his rebuttal career cut out for him… But, I don’t want to stop there because I wish to really dissect his response.

(I COULD HAVE STOPPED THE ARTICLE HERE… BUT I CONTINUED…)

ENDEARING, FORLORN, EMBARRASSMENT

First off, I need to correct the rancher in that the article said, “They always give me that endearing look”…  Just to be clear, that means that the look is endearing to me, not that they have a look on their faces of endearment.  However, I’m not saying that horses cannot feel endearment, but actually, I don’t think I have ever seen that look from them.  I think they like me and some may love me, but they don’t look at me endearingly.  My dog looks at me endearingly, but not my horses.

Anyway, more to the point.  I did write that my horses gave me forlorn expressions when they were caught in a gate.  And I did say that they looked embarrassed when I discovered them stuck.

Yes, those are my words to describe what I felt from them.  I don’t know the equine’s terminology for that expression I was seeing on their faces and the mood I was feeling from them.  But, since I am writing as a human to humans, I wrote what I felt and what I thought humans would understand.

DEGREE OF QUALIFICATION OF EMOTION?

Has the rancher never used emotional adjectives to describe his horse… is this possible?  Has he never said “rank” or “sore” or “spooky” or “good” before?  And, are those words just adjectives?  Or, are those words the rancher’s impressions of what he feels the horse is feeling?  If he has ever used those terms, I’m guessing that he crossed that emotional bridge without even realizing it…

But maybe the rancher is just limiting the range of emotions he thinks animals can possess… or more to the point, he is limiting the range of emotions he is willing to allow his horses to feel.  For example, horses can feel pain and feel anger, but they cannot be hurt or frustrated…

ADDING SOME HEART

The expression that a racehorse has “heart” means what?  Or other well known human terms for equine expressions would be “he’s got fire” or “fury” or “presence”.  Are those emotional expressions?  And, we all know that stallions protect their herds… What are these terms besides anthropomorphising?

A PRIVATE PHONE INSTALLED

Lastly, I want to address the rancher’s idea of having a private phone installed for Aladdin to call me.  First of all, we know this won’t work because I have no reception down at the barn.  But it is also kinda silly.  After all, it is quite clearly documented that horses communicate telepathically with each other.  How else would herds know which way to run?  Horses have no use for phones, duh.

DEGREES OF QUALIFICATION

In conclusion, all we humans can do is put ourselves in the equine’s hooves or rancher’s shoes and try to think from that perspective —  Or at least that is our job as animal stewards.

Having said that… perhaps what the rancher was really saying is that complexity of emotions in animals is a tough concept for him.  Perhaps I could say that he has potentially lived on a ranch all his life and has steeled himself to all the hardships the animals endure by ignoring the effects of those hardships on his stock.  Or maybe this idea of animals not having human characteristics was handed down through generations of ranching dogma.  Or, maybe he lost his beloved dog as a child and has blocked out the pain by refusing to go there ever again.

Or, maybe the rancher has forgotten the single attribute of human characteristic or behavior that cannot be applied to a god, animal, or object… humanity.

As an addendum, one reader suggested that animals have more humanity than some people…  And, I would agree.  However, my statement above was not suggesting that animals do not have the characteristics we apply to the definition of ‘humanity’, merely saying that humanity, by definition, is a human quality.

 


Riding Warehouse
Your purchase with Riding Warehouse through this link helps the Bucket Fund!


Supporting The Bucket Fund through Amazon Smile
Please choose HORSE AND MAN, INC when you shop via Amazon Smile through this link.



HORSE AND MAN is a blog in growth... if you like this, please pass it around!



How I have Vitality again – Managing Lyme Disease






Many of you have asked how I am doing regarding my Lyme Disease.  Many of you have told me that you also have auto-immune diseases – or have friends who suffer – and would like to know what I have learned.

So, today is the day!

Please know that I believe each human has individual symptoms according to their constitution. So, what I have done for myself may not be exactly correct for any other person.

Also, I know how frustrating it is for auto-immune sufferers to try many different protocols – to no avail.  Truly, I was almost to the brink – so I have great empathy for those who are looking for relief and have tried almost everything.

I am not a Doctor – and I am guessing that most doctors would not have experience with what I have posted below.  I am only telling you all what I did to help myself.

HOW LYME EFFECTED ME

For many years, I have been very sore in the joints of my knees and hips.  Feeding the horses was a trial for a very long time… riding was out of the question because Lyme has effected my brain and coordination.  I did not feel stable in the saddle.

I was no longer was able to do my job well  (commercial producer) due to the stress, long hours and physical strength needed to endure the high pressure and lack of sleep.  This was the most upsetting for me.  I was not who I used to be.

WHAT I TRIED THAT DIDN’T WORK

The specialists put me on Doxycyline for 9 months.  I have been on the strongest anti-inflammatories available.   I have been prescribed several auto-immune suppressors.  For me, they didn’t help.

I’ve tried many homeopathic and naturopathic tinctures (hair of the dog) that were created to jump start the immune system.  For me, the herxing (the symptoms that arise) was too great for me to continue.

WHAT I DID THAT IS HELPING ME GREATLY

*Please know that these are not ‘cures’.  I know they are not cures because if I fall off the wagon, I immediately notice weakness again.  However, I have never fallen to the depths of how I felt when I wasn’t doing these protocols.

DIET

The first thing I did for myself was follow the Paleo diet for immuno diseases.  Basically, this is eating NOTHING white.  No sugar, no flour, no dairy.

It also says to have no root vegetables, no tomatoes and no eggs.

This is tough.  But, if you do most of this, you will feel much better.  (I still have wine and ice cream occasionally …. but for the most part,  If I stick to this diet , I feel much better.)

I also make a protein and vitamin packed smoothie every morning.  Here are two ingredients that have helped me.  Sun Warrior Protein Powder and Dr. Schultze’s Super Food. After using both of these products every morning, I notice a significant change in my entire day. Another great benefit of a morning drink is that I am not tempted to eat bread products or dairy. So that helps.  (Don’t forget to add magnesium to your diet – or take a supplement.)

CELL BOOSTING

It was interesting… my specialist at UC Davis told me that there is no cure for auto-immune diseases.  He told me that I had to re-train my cells since I had pushed them into ‘high alert’ by my constant over stress..

Well, behold this… who knew?!  A way to help your cells relearn stasis. No more constant ‘high alert’ – which is a layman’s way of explaining ‘auto-immune response’.

I put a drop on the bottom of my foot before I go to bed.  This bottle will last a very long time.

ESSENTIAL MINERALS, VITAMINS AND OILS

Ok, this was the last step that I have taken which put me over the hump. When I swallow these pills religiously, I notice a huge difference in my day.  HUGE.  I would recommend these supplements to anyone with an auto-immune disease – or any kind of disease.  *Note, please make sure you don’t have any allergies to the ingredients.

Do-Terra Lifelong Vitality Pack.  I highly recommend this Vitality Pack.  I believe this is what has boosted me to where I am today.  I feel pretty good most of the time now!  I’m happy, hopeful and have the ability to exercise.

These products have really, really changed my life.

IF I GET RUN DOWN OR FEEL A COLD COMING ON…

Sometimes, I overdo it and feel run down.  When that happens, I find that a drop of each of these oils (Melissa and On Guard) in water, stops the ‘ugh, I’m getting sick’ feeling.  I have not had a cold since I’ve been taking these.  I also have not had a huge Lyme flare.

NOT PROMOTING ANY BRAND… No affiliations.

These are the specific items that work well for me.  I have no affiliation.


Riding Warehouse
Your purchase with Riding Warehouse through this link helps the Bucket Fund!


Supporting The Bucket Fund through Amazon Smile
Please choose HORSE AND MAN, INC when you shop via Amazon Smile through this link.



HORSE AND MAN is a blog in growth... if you like this, please pass it around!